Book your William Penn Inn reservation on Resy

Mrs. Penn's Bakery

All William Penn Inn-baked products are completely hand made from the freshest, finest, all-natural ingredients and are readily available with only 24 hours notice. Please call (215) 699-9272 to place your order from Tuesday Through Sunday 10am-6pm.

All pricing listed is for take-out only.

Cakes

STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE
Layers of light vanilla sponge cake,
sweet whipped European cream and
fresh strawberries; finished with
white chocolate curls and fresh berries
(6-8 slices) $30.00

TIRAMISU
Twelve individual portions of Italian espresso
sponge cake layered with a mascarpone
& Marsala mousse; finished with whipped
cream & chocolate curls
$37.00

CHOCOLATE HEAVEN CAKE
A delicate chocolate sponge cake filled with
white chocolate mousse; iced with chocolate
whipped cream
(10-12 slices) $32.00

BUTTER CRUMB CAKE
Classic light vanilla breakfast cake topped with
a rich, buttery cinnamon streusel; festively
packaged in a holiday tin
(8-10 slices) $17.00

Miniature Pastries

24 assorted pieces; chocolate-covered strawberries, tiramisu squares, raspberry tortes mini New York cheesecakes, pecan squares and lemon blueberry tarts.
(24 hours notice required) $34.00

Pies

BOURBON PECAN PIE
A Southern tradition; plump with pecans
and a molasses & bourbon filling
(8-10 slices) $25.00

PUMPKIN PIE
Mrs. Penn’s own recipe! A flaky shell filled with
a creamy cinnamon and ginger-spiced pumpkin
custard; decorated with a golden pastry leaf
(8-10 slices) $22.00

PEANUT BUTTER PIE
A peanut butter lover’s must; luscious layers
of chocolate cream, Reese’s Cups and peanut
butter mousse; garnished with whipped
cream, peanut butter chips and chocolate
(8-10 slices) $26.00

KEY LIME PIE
Key lime custard baked in a traditional Graham
cracker crust; garnished with whipped cream
and a lime twist
(8-10 slices) $22.00

APPLE CRUMB PIE
A delicious combination of fresh apples with
a sour cream custard; topped with buttery
cinnamon, brown sugar and walnut crumbs
(8-10 slices) $28.00

Cheesecakes

NEW YORK STYLE CHEESECAKE
For cheesecake lovers – rich and creamy;
topped with sour cream and a festive
raspberry swirl
Large (12-14 slices) $35.00
Small (6-8 slices) $22.00

BAILEY’S CHEESECAKE
A creamy Bailey’s flavored cheesecake presented
on an Oreo cookie crust; topped with miniature chocolate curls
Small only
(6-8 slices) $24.00

LIMONCELLO CHEESECAKE
Creamy lemon cheesecake on a buttery Graham
cracker crust; topped with a decadent white
chocolate Limoncello glaze and garnished
with candied lemon zest and blueberries
Small only
(6-8 slices) $24.00